We explore the inversion of derivatives prices to obtain an implied
probability measure on volatility's hidden state. Stochastic volatility is a
hidden Markov model (HMM), and HMMs ordinarily warrant filtering. However,
derivative data is a set of conditional expectations that are already observed
in the market, so rather than use filtering techniques we compute an
\textit{implied distribution} by inverting the market's option prices.
Robustness is an issue when model parameters are probably unknown, but isn't
crippling in practical settings because the data is sufficiently imprecise and
prevents us from reducing the fitting error down to levels where parameter
uncertainty will show. When applied to SPX data, the estimated model and
implied distributions produce variance swap rates that are consistent with the
VIX, and also pick up some of the monthly effects that occur from option
expiration. We find that parsimony of the Heston model is beneficial because we
are able to decipher behavior in estimated parameters and implied measures,
whereas the richer Heston model with jumps produces a better fit but also has
implied behavior that is less revealing.