Remember me

Register  |   Lost password?


arXiv logo for blog page

Reality-check for Econophysics: Likelihood-based fitting of physics-inspired market models to empirical data. (arXiv:1803.03861v1 [cs.CE])

Mon, 12 Mar 2018 20:19:01 GMT

The statistical description and modeling of volatility plays a prominent role
in econometrics, risk management and finance. GARCH and stochastic volatility
models have been extensively studied and are routinely fitted to market data,
albeit providing a phenomenological description only.

In contrast, the field of econophysics starts from the premise that modern
economies consist of a vast number of individual actors with heterogeneous
expectations and incentives. In turn explaining observed market statistics as
emerging from the collective dynamics of many actors following heterogeneous,
yet simple, rather mechanistic rules. While such models generate volatility
dynamics qualitatively matching several stylized facts and thus illustrate the
possible role of different mechanisms, such as chartist trading, herding
behavior etc., rigorous and quantitative statistical fits are still mostly

Here, we show how Stan, a modern probabilistic programming language for
Bayesian modeling, can be used to fit several models from econophysics. In
contrast to the method of moment matching, which is currently popular, our fits
are purely likelihood based with many advantages, including systematic model
comparison and principled generation of model predictions conditional on the
observed price history. In particular, we investigate models by Vikram & Sinha
and Franke & Westerhoff, and provide a quantitative comparison with standard
econometric models.